Michaels New York Style Pizza in Paducah

All Pizza Companies, should make a Pizza like they do.

Food is good. If I lived in paducah I'd order and bring home often. I dont recommend eating inside sadly. Rest rooms where terribly dirty, and atmosphere is pretty bad. But the pizza is great.

I’ve order from them many times . I’ve been ordering from them on my own since I was 16 , I’m 19 now lol I love there’s subs , chicken fingers & the cheesecake .

I usually love this place, but after tonight I'm done. I ordered wings, among other things... I had it delivered. When I opened them up, they were tiny. They had no meat on them at all and they were all smaller than my pinky, and I have small fingers. I asked if they could switch them out, or if I could get my money back .I ordered these same wings three days ago and they were double this size. They told me if I wanted my money back then I'd have to bring them up there. I got them delivered because I don't have a vehicle. Before I could get another word in they hung up. They were rude as hell. They lost a loyal costumer tonight. I took pics too. Will post them as soon as I find out how. Take a normal size house key in your hand and they were as small as that. And hardly no meat on them at all .they should have corrected this issue.

Great food, we've went twice in one week and still have so much left to try. Very friendly staff, family oriented, very accommodating. Our new favorite place and that says a lot because I manage a pizza place.

Just tried this place to day with some friendsHad pizza and subs both are good I would recommend this place for sure its nothing fancy but good food.cozy atmosphere

Excellent..real deal pizza and great toasted sandwiches. Best lunch spot in the city.

Good food, quick service. What more could a fella ask for?

We are traveling through and asked the staff at the Homewoood Suites where to get pizza. She suggested Michael’s and said it was really good. She was RIGHT! We spent some time in the Tampa Bay area and loved Rick’s NY Style pizza and haven’t had anything like it or as good until tonight! Thank you for great pizza and bringing back some wonderful memories!!!

This is my favorite local pizza place! I am so excited this was the first place I chose to eat inside post COVID-19. They are doing a FANTASTIC job!!! And the food is AMAZING as always!

New York style pizza made fresh to order. Their lunch special is awesome and will fill a grown man no issue.

Everything at this restaurant is delicious. Baked spaghetti, subs and pizza are the best around. When my family comes to visit I will bring them here.

Lunch special was a great price and the pizza was great. Building has the feel of a good old fashioned place, not new and sterile.

This is straight from Brooklyn. They have great food and service.

I am recently transplanted from the east coast and have lived in sight of Manhattan. Anyone who says this is anything like NY pizza has never been there. Sorry but the pepperoni and mushroom pizza I got there today was bland. The crust was decent, but the ingredients and seasoning were about as far from NY pizzeria as Paducah is from Manhattan. I also got the lasagna special. It was cooked well and noodles were good but the sauce was just tomatoey. Short on meat and spice. Ambiance and service were great. Prices were reasonable. I will go back and try the subs and maybe one of the specialty pies, but I will be looking for a better go to pizzeria.

I would rate their pizza a solid 12 out of 10! Fresh hand made sauce and crust.

Always wonderful service and the food quality is unmatched. It's my favorite place to eat.

Great place to eat. Owners are extremely friendly.

Actual New York style pizza!! We love.the pizza here.

Great food, great customer service. A real New Yorker owns the place. It's not one of those fake new York style restaurants. 😂

lady at the register was so rude! We brought a party of 12 in and all she could do is complain that she had lunch hour coming in. So much for southern hospitality.

Great pizza. Nice New York style atmosphere to enjoy true Brooklyn style pizza and a nice cold beer.

One of the best places to get pizza in Paducah.

Good pizza. Good prices. Acceptable speed.

Only been here once and it was fabulous! I chose the loaded calzone. I should probably just go ahead and give it five stars now as my belt notches increase! 😉🍕

Awesome Pizza. Comfortable atmosphere. Friendly staff. The rest of the menu has great reviews also.

Always great pizza and service!

I love this place , its fast , well priced and delicious.

Never had a bad meal! Service and delivery are excellent! Love it!

Delicious food, great service!

The best pizza in town in my opinion. I've had pizza from New York. This is as close as you will get. Mike is from Brooklyn I think. Great guy hard working and makes a mean pizza. Subs are awesome too. If you order two slices and a drink you better be hungry.

I am from Syracuse, NY and have lived in Alabama for the past 14 years. I travel for work often and always look for a local pizza shop. Came across Michaels on google. Stopped in and ordered a large cheese pizza. The friendly woman at the counter told me I would get some some good NY style pizza. She was right. I thought the pizza was great! I will be eating here a few times while I’m in town for work!

The friendliest people work here. Was visiting from out of town and they are so kind and make you feel right at home. My daughters and I each had a personal 9 inch pizza and it was very good. 2 thumbs up.

Great food. Use to know the owner. Not sure who runs it now. But still great.

Very Good. Recomend Highly. Go For It.

Food was great and staff was very friendly and helpful,,highly recomend

Michael's Pizzeria of Paducah is a great New York Style Pizza Pie and Submarine Sandwiches Shop! Michael and the Team use fresh ingredients and great pie dough combined with years of personal experience and know-how to bring this community and their many patrons years and years of great food. Located on the corner of S. 9th St. And Kentucky Ave. here in Paducah in an old Burger Chef Restaurant Building Michael's brings you the BEST in East Coast flare and flavor with a down home Kentucky Bluegrass hospitality that's must see to believe! We aren't just customers to Michael we're; family, friends and neighbors for life. Michael's New York Pizza is a definite must see and try restaurant in Paducah. See you there!

This is a great old school pizza place with a throwback interior and fantastic food!!

I love this place. A great piece to get your ny style pizza.

There isn't enough good things I can say about Michael's. I have been going there for many years, it is always the same. 😋👍🏽Mostly all the same friendly people working there, same great service, and delicious pizza. The location may seem out of the way for some, but definitely worth a little extra drive. 🍕👨🏽‍🍳👩🏻‍💼💯✅😍

Real pizza. Not like those chain pizza places. Fresh made dough, cooked in a real pizza oven. Great flavor, friendly staff. Highly recommended.

First of all it had a warm comfortable feeling about it one I can't explain I just felt at home there. While the pizza is great I usually go for the Italian beef sub, with potatoe salad that rivals with what my mom used to make not quite grannys but definitely deserves to be noted and cheesecake is quite good too. This establishment also serves ice cold beer if that's your wish but a all around great restaurant which I have been to several times and will continue to return to. My go to when all else fails I urge have you not been you have to try it I absolutely love this place.

Top notch Pizza and Calzone sat in my truck and went into food coma city lol!

Michael's Pizza is a true gem. An authentic New York Style Pizza joint, right here in Western Kentucky. The place itself has a cool, genuine pizza shop vibe, and the people that run it contribute to that vibe. You can expect to hear a friendly yankee-style "Hey, hi-ya doin' neh buddy" as you walk through the door, and I love the idea of supporting a local pizza joint, just trying to make a living like the rest of us, instead of some pizza chain you can get anywhere. There's something about their pizza that keeps me coming back. Being New York Style Pizza, it's pretty thin pizza, so there's nothing crazy special about it, but it's still good enough to somehow get me to eat more than I do from any other pizza place. There's something about that classic, minimalist pizza that I love.

I like quiet environment and food is awesome.

Michaels has the most mouth watering meatball subs you will ever sink your teeth into. Pizza is the bomb too!! Great prices, service and location. I'll be back or I'll call for delivery.

Delicious pizza!!! I got lasagna and was so full from the pizza I just brought it home. They make their own sauce and it was absolutely delicious!! I think we just found our new favorite place! Reasonably priced for all that you get, very friendly and welcoming staff. Highly recommended!

Hands down the best local pizzeria. The food is delicious and fairly priced, the decor is fun, and I'm consistently impressed with the friendliness of the staff. Delivery is prompt too, so your food will arrive fresh and hot. If you're not in the mood for pizza, try the subs - the Italian beef is to die for! My only complain about Michael's is the entrance could be a bit more handicap accessible, but staff and customers alike have always been helpful with holding doors to help out.

Best place to come and eat

By far the best and most authentic New York style pizza I've had. Only pizza joint I'll go to